Best Pizza restaurants in New York – The full list
New York is one of the world’s great pizza cities, not because it has one kind of perfect pizza, but because it has so many. A single pizza crawl can move from a classic Village slice shop to a coal-oven institution, from a dollar-slice counter near Grand Central to a creative late-night pizzeria near MacDougal Street, from East Harlem history to a spicy square slice on Prince Street.
This guide brings together some of the best pizza restaurants in New York, covering old-school New York slices, sit-down Italian restaurants with strong pizza programs, Neapolitan-style pies, coal-oven classics, affordable pizza counters, vegan-friendly options, and quick slices built for late-night cravings. Some are built for a fast slice, some are better for a full dinner, and others are the kind of places that help explain why pizza is such a central part of eating in New York.
Joe’s Pizza
Joe’s Pizza is one of New York’s most famous slice shops, and the Carmine Street location is the one many people picture when they think of a classic New York slice. The appeal is simple: thin crust, tomato sauce, mozzarella, a foldable slice, and the kind of fast-moving counter energy that feels unmistakably Greenwich Village.
This is not a long, leisurely restaurant meal. Joe’s is best when you want a quick slice, a late-night stop, a casual bite while walking through the Village, or a straightforward example of New York pizza without too many distractions. It works because it understands the form: hot slice, paper plate, quick service, and the city moving around you.
Address: 7 Carmine Street, New York, NY 10014
Menu: View the Joe’s Pizza menu
Harry’s Italian
Harry’s Italian brings a more relaxed, sit-down Italian approach to pizza in the Financial District. It is not only a pizza stop; it is a full Italian restaurant with pasta, chicken and veal dishes, salads, appetizers, wine, and both round and square pies. That makes it especially useful for groups who want pizza on the table but also want a broader Italian meal.
The location near offices, hotels, and lower Manhattan attractions makes Harry’s Italian a practical choice for lunch, after-work meals, family dinners, and casual nights downtown. It is especially good when you want pizza to be part of a bigger spread rather than the whole event. Order a few pies, add pasta or mains, and treat it as an easy group meal.
Address: 2 Gold Street, New York, NY 10038
Menu: View the Harry’s Italian menu
Zia Maria Chelsea
Zia Maria Chelsea is a full-service Italian restaurant and pizzeria in Chelsea, with a menu built around Neapolitan-style pizza, pasta, Italian classics, drinks, and a comfortable dining room. It is a useful choice when you want pizza but still want the structure of a sit-down restaurant rather than a quick slice counter.
The restaurant works well for casual dinners, groups, family meals, and visitors spending time around Chelsea, the High Line, or the west side. Its strength is flexibility: you can make pizza the main event, or you can treat it as part of a larger Italian meal with antipasti, pasta, drinks, and shared plates.
Address: 318 West 23rd Street, New York, NY 10011
Menu: View the Zia Maria Chelsea menu
Pasquale Jones
Pasquale Jones is one of the best choices in New York when you want pizza in a restaurant setting that feels polished, energetic, and wine-focused. Located on Mulberry Street, it is known for wood-fired cooking, pizza, meats, fish, and a dining room that feels more like a serious downtown restaurant than a simple pizzeria.
This is a strong pick for date nights, dinners with food-focused friends, and anyone who wants pizza with a little more ceremony. The pies are part of the appeal, but so is the whole meal: wine, small plates, fire-driven cooking, and the buzz of a compact Nolita/Little Italy dining room. Pasquale Jones shows how pizza can move comfortably into a more elevated downtown restaurant experience.
Address: 187 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10012
Menu: View the Pasquale Jones menu
John’s of Bleecker Street
John’s of Bleecker Street is one of New York’s most important old-school pizzerias. It is a Greenwich Village institution with a coal-fired brick oven, a long history, and the kind of dining room that feels deeply connected to New York pizza culture. Unlike slice shops, John’s is about whole pies, which makes it better for sitting down with friends than grabbing a quick slice on the sidewalk.
The best way to experience John’s is with a group, a whole pizza or two, and enough time to enjoy the room. The pies have the character people want from coal-oven New York pizza: a crisp crust, a firm base, and a classic balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. It is one of the places that helps explain why New York pizza history still matters.
Address: 278 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014
Menu: View the John’s of Bleecker Street menu
99 Cent Fresh Pizza
99 Cent Fresh Pizza represents another essential side of New York pizza: the quick, affordable slice counter. While pricing at some dollar-slice shops has shifted over time, the idea remains the same. This is pizza built for speed, value, and convenience, especially in Midtown where commuters, office workers, students, and visitors all need something fast.
This is not a special-occasion pizza restaurant, and it does not need to be. Its purpose is different. It is for a quick lunch, a late-night bite, a slice between trains, or a no-fuss meal when you want something hot and filling without sitting down. In a city where pizza can be historic, chef-driven, or expensive, the value slice still has a place.
Address: 151 East 43rd Street, New York, NY 10017
Menu: View the 99 Cent Fresh Pizza menu
Artistic Pizza
Artistic Pizza brings a creative, late-night slice-shop energy to Greenwich Village. Located near MacDougal Street and West 3rd Street, it is the kind of pizzeria that suits students, neighborhood regulars, night owls, and anyone looking for a fast pizza stop around Washington Square Park. The menu includes classic slices and pies, but it also stands out for vegan and gluten-free options, which makes it more flexible than many traditional slice counters.
This is a good choice when the group wants options. You can keep things simple with a cheese slice or pepperoni, or go for something more specific like vegan pepperoni, a vegan margherita, chicken bacon ranch, gluten-free pizza, or a full pie to share. Artistic Pizza adds a modern Village slice-shop angle to this list: casual, quick, creative, and useful late into the night.
Address: 123 West 3rd Street, New York, NY 10012
Menu: View the Artistic Pizza menu
Rosemary’s Pizza
Rosemary’s Pizza brings pizza into the world of a bright, ingredient-driven West Village Italian restaurant. Rosemary’s is known more broadly as a neighborhood Italian restaurant, but its pizza offering fits the same spirit: fresh, casual, and designed for diners who want Italian food in a warm downtown setting.
This is a good option when the group wants more than pizza alone. You can build a meal around pizza, pasta, vegetables, salads, wine, and a relaxed Village atmosphere. It works for brunch, lunch, dinner, dates, and casual group meals, especially when you want pizza in a restaurant that also gives you a broader Italian menu.
Address: 18 Greenwich Avenue, New York, NY 10011
Menu: View the Rosemary’s Pizza menu
Patsy’s Pizza
Patsy’s Pizza in East Harlem is one of the city’s classic names, with a history tied to New York’s coal-oven pizza tradition. It is the kind of pizzeria people seek out because it feels connected to an older version of the city: Italian Harlem, thin-crust pies, simple toppings, and the idea that pizza does not need to be reinvented to be memorable.
This is a strong choice for pizza lovers who want to understand the roots of New York pizza beyond the most obvious downtown slice shops. Patsy’s works for lunch, dinner, casual groups, and anyone who wants a classic pie in a neighborhood that has played an important role in the city’s Italian-American food history.
Address: 2287 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10035
Menu: View the Patsy’s Pizza menu
Prince Street Pizza
Prince Street Pizza is one of New York’s most recognizable modern slice shops, especially for its square slices. The Prince Street location is the original, and it has become a destination for people looking for a bold, saucy, crisp-edged square slice with a strong downtown following.
This is a good stop when you want a slice with more punch than the classic plain cheese slice. Prince Street Pizza is especially associated with thick square slices, crispy edges, and pepperoni cups, making it a strong choice for visitors, late-night eaters, and pizza fans doing a Nolita or SoHo food crawl.
Address: 27 Prince Street, New York, NY 10012
Menu: View the Prince Street Pizza menu
Final Thoughts
The best pizza restaurants in New York show how many different ways the city eats pizza. Joe’s Pizza and 99 Cent Fresh Pizza represent the quick-slice tradition. John’s of Bleecker Street and Patsy’s Pizza carry the weight of old-school New York pizza history. Prince Street Pizza adds the modern square-slice energy that has become famous far beyond Nolita.
For a more restaurant-driven pizza meal, Harry’s Italian, Zia Maria Chelsea, Pasquale Jones, and Rosemary’s Pizza each offer a different version of Italian dining with pizza at the center or close to it. Artistic Pizza rounds out the list with a creative Greenwich Village slice-shop option that is especially useful for late-night eating, vegan choices, gluten-free options, and casual pies near MacDougal Street. Together, these restaurants show why pizza remains one of New York’s defining foods: it can be fast, cheap, historic, polished, casual, creative, destination-worthy, and deeply satisfying, often within the same few neighborhoods.